Lê Hoàng Việt
  • Home
  • Literature Review and Analysis
  • Cartography
  • Armor Blog
  • Discourse
  • Essays
  • Home
  • Literature Review and Analysis
  • Cartography
  • Armor Blog
  • Discourse
  • Essays
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

​Cartography

11/17/2024 0 Comments

The Twelfth Battle of the Isonzo: the First day of Battle October 24th 1917

Note:
  • To avoid confusion, Central Powers' troop is in blue and Italian troops is in red.
  • Different names of locations are listed at the end of this post.

Weather Condition:

​Bad weather continued to play a huge part on October 24th. For weeks the Isonzo front was under heavy rains and thick clouds. On the 24th, snowstorms occurred on high-elevation This terrible weather played a significant role during the offensive

​The Neutralization of Italian artillery batteries.

​At 2:00 AM on October 24th, the German first artillery barrage signaled the beginning of the offensive. This barrage was to neutralize the Italian guns and their first line of trenches. The majority of those munitions were poison gas shells.​
Picture
German Preparing Gas Mortars
The Italians immediately attempted to retaliate but their powerful searchlights struggled to pinpoint the enemy batteries due to thick fog.

Cloudy weather did not hinder the attackers’ accuracy, as the Germans had set their targets mathematically days ago. 

Many Italian troops were killed without realizing they were poisoned. The fog hid the distinct yellow color.

Around 700 men from the 87th Infantry Regiment (~70 percent of their combatants) were killed immediately north of Flitsch. When the Austrians reached their position, they found no gas masks on the victims.

​​
Picture
An Austro-Hungarian searchlight. The Italian used several similar search lights on Oct 24th. Imperial War Museum
Picture
Fallen Italian victims of the gas attack
Picture
WW1 Memorials of the 700 fallen Italian victims of the gas attack.
Even though the Italians used masks, the new chlorine-arsenic argent rendered them useless after two hours of usage. Eventually, the Italians decided to abandon their position and left their guns behind. 

Poison gas shells were not the only reason the Italian’s batteries were ineffective.
The doctrine’s complexity and the rigid centralized command were to blame.

​Because of the constant shortage of ammunition, the March 1917 Artillery Doctrine dictated that the best time to unleash a counterfire was right after the enemy’s destructive barrage. After the destructive barrage ended, an enemy infantry attack would surely follow. Thus the counter barrage at that moment would inflict the maximum damage to the attackers. 

When their positions were under fire, the Italians could not tell if it was a destructive barrage or not due to darkness and foggy weather. The doctrine was also overcomplicated on which specific guns and shells to use. 

Artillery Commanders such as General Guiliano Ricci and Colonel Alfredo Connoniere ordered their batteries to attack immediately. But the Vice Commander of the 2nd Army Pietro Badoglio overruled them. Badoglio explained on the telephone, “We only have munitions for three days and I don’t know if I can let you have any of it. At any rate, we’ll see.”

Thus the intensity of the Italian counter battery decreased. By 4:30 AM, most of the defender’s guns were silenced. 
Picture
Pietro Badoglio, Vice Commander of the 2nd Army

At 6:30 AM, 2,000 guns from the Central Powers unleashed a destructive barrage from Mt. Rombom to Görz. Their targets were fortifications, munition depots, headquarters, and especially communication centers. Many of the telephone lines were destroyed.

Badoglio could not give the order for a counter battery when the Austro-German infantry attacked at 7:30 AM. The local artillery officers did not dare open fire without an order from the headquarters. They were also oblivious to the struggling infantry in the forward positions. ​
Picture
Effective Range of the main guns. Redrawn and Translated from The Austrian Last War, Vol 4, Leaflet 013.

​Infantry Attack on the First Day

​Krauss’ Group: The austro-hungarian i corps

​Their primary objective was Saga (Žaga). Saga was strategically important. First, the Isonzo near it was narrow enough that troops could move across. To the south-west lay Mt. Stol a vital location for the defenders. To the southeast was a major road to Karfreit through Serpenizza and Trnovavo.

​To reach Saga, the orders of Krauss’s Group were:


The Austro-Hungarian 22nd Schützen Division would make a breakthrough at Flitsch (Bovec, Plezzo) before storming the ruins of Pod Celom. Once Pod Celom was captured, they would advance to Saga. 
​
the Austro-Hungarian 3rd "Edelweiss" Infantry Division would attack Mt. Rombom to protect the right flanks of the 22nd Division. Simultaneously, the 59th Infantry Brigade from the 10th Army would also launch an attack on Mt. Rombom from the north. 
Picture
Alfred Krauss. Commander of the Austro-Hungarian I Corps
To the south of the 22nd Division, the Austro-Hungarian 55th Infantry Division would storm Planina za Kraju through the Vršič Pass. 

Saga (Zaga) was strategically important. This was where the Isonzo was narrowed enough for troops to move across. It was connected to Karfreit by a major south-east road through Serpenizza and Trnovavo. ​
Picture
Austro-Hungarian I Corps, October 24th 1917.

AUstro-Hungarian 22nd Schützen Division:

Picture
A Photo of Flitsch Area taken in October 1917. The direction of attack of the 22nd Schützen Division.
Picture
The Advance of the 22nd Schützen Division October 24th.
​At 9:00 AM, the 22nd Division captured the first Italian trenches north of Flitsch. They found no survivors of the gas attack. At the ruins of Flitsch, the Italian defenders from the 50th Infantry Division offered some resistance. Eventually, the Austrians took Flitsch before noon. 

By the evening, the 22nd Division broke through the 3rd line. Pod Celom and Pluzne fell to the Austrian hands.

The 22nd Schützen Division could not reach Saga. Their advance exceeded their artillery bombardment schedule, putting them at risk of friendly fire. As they could not establish communication with their batteries, they halted their assault for the day.

The 22nd Schützen Division took 3000 prisoners, 36 artillery pieces, and 50 machine guns on the first day.
Picture
The Town of Flitsch before the Great War.
Picture
Captured Italian guns at Flitsch's main square. Kobariški Muzej (Kobarid Museum)

Austro-Hungarian 216th Brigade of the 3rd Infantry Division:

Picture
​The attack on Mt. Rombom (2208m) failed. A snowstorm on those heights weakened the effect of the gas attack. As the 216th Brigade fought hard to reach the first trenches, they discovered that their artillery barrages failed to damage the barbed wires. They were forced to retreat back to their starting point under intense fire from machine guns ​
Picture
An Austro-Hungarian field telephone outpost on Mt Rombon. 1917. Rare Historical Photos
Picture
Central Powers troops in snow camouflage cutting through barbed wire lines. Imperial War Museum
Meanwhile, the 59th Mountain Brigade was stopped at the Seebach Valley, unable to assist the assault on Mt. Rombom. 

Mt. Rombom remained in the Italian hands.

Austro-Hungarian 55th Infantry Division:

Picture
​The 55th Infantry Division’s assault on Vršič (Moistrocca) (1897m) was equally a struggle. The icy condition not only greatly diminished the effectiveness of the gas barrage but delayed their attack to two hours. This gave the Italian 43rd Division valuable time to strengthen their defense.

At 9:30, as the weather improved, the Austrian attack began after setting off a huge explosion underneath Vršič. While the 55th Division easily captured the first line, they could not reach Vrata, the Dol Plateau, and Planinaza Kraju as planned.

The 43rd Infantry Division fought back fiercely. Not knowing that Karfreit fell at 4:00 PM, they launched a ferocious counterattack that effectively drove the infantry of the 55th Division back to Vršič.

When the news of Karfreit and the retreating order finally reached them around 9:00 PM, it was too late. Confusion, hunger, and exhaustion took over their fighting spirit. Their retreat was disorganized, leaving many guns and heavy equipment behind. Eventually, the 43rd Division and their commander Lieutenant General Farisoglio surrendered to the Germans at Karfreit.
Picture
Austrian troops moving through the Vršič Pass. November 1917

​Stein’s Group: the iii royal bavarian army corps

Picture
View of the Area from Tolmein Height. Taken October 1917
​Stein’s groups included: the Austro-Hungarian 50th Infantry Division, the German Silesian 12th Division, the German 117th Division, and the Alpenkorps.

Stein’s main objectives were (1) The town of Karfreit and (2) the principal fortification on Mt. Matajur on the Kolovrat. 

Karfreit was important to the Italians on the western side of the Isonzo. There were no major roads to their position at the Vršič Pass, the Krn Plateau, and the Mrzli Vrh Ridge. If Karfreit was captured, the 43rd and 46th Infantry Divisions would be cut off. 

Despite its strategic location, the Italians deployed very few men and guns to defend the Isonzo valley between Karfreit and Tolmein where the two major roads on both banks of the Isonzo were. Instead, their troops were concentrated on the heights of the Kolovrat and the Mrzli Vrh.

​The Italian high command believed any enemy movement to the valley would be an easy target for batteries on the high ground. Yet the defenders’ guns were quiet on October 24th.​
Picture
Hermann Freiherr von Stein. Commander of the III Royal Bavarian Army Corps.
Picture
To accomplish Sein’s objectives:
  • The German Silesian 12th Infantry Division would launch a swift attack in the Isonzo Valley from the Tolmein bridgehead to Karfreit. Once Karfreit was taken, they would continue eastward deeper into the enemy territory. 
  • The German Alpenkorps would climb the Kolovrat to storm a strong fortification at Hill 1114. This would take the Italian attention away from the 12th Division below the valley. In addition, controlling Hill 1114 would open a door to Mt. Matajur.
  • The Austro-Hungarian 50th Infantry Division would secure the Krn and Mrzili to protect the right flank of the 12th Division.

The Austro-Hungarian 50th Infantry Division:

Picture
Austro-Hungarian Storm Troopers (Assault Troops, Stoßtruppen) in 1917
Picture
​At 8:00 AM, a mine was detonated under the Krn. Soon, men of the 50th Division took the Krn Plateau, surrounding the enemy at the Krn Summit.  

At 11:00 the 3rd Mountain Brigade captured Krn Village while the 15th Mountain Brigade continued their advance along the Mrzli Vrn ridge and captured Gabrije
.
Without support from their heavy batteries, the Italian 46th Infantry Division resisted strongly as it retreated to the 2nd positions Kozljak - Pleca - Vrsno - Selisce. 

In the afternoon the 15th Mountain Brigade joined the right column of the 12th Infantry Division. Together, they overwhelmed the defenders at Ladra in the evening, effectively cutting off the 46th and 43rd Division from retreating east of the Isonzo.

The 50th Infantry Division took 7000 prisoners and 90 guns on the first day.
Picture
Troops of the 3rd Mountain Brigade scale the slopes of Krn. 1917. Rare Historical Photos
Picture
Picture
Austro-Hungarian troops examining captured heavy Italian artillery guns. Imperial War Museum.

The 12th German Silesian Infantry Division 

Picture
View from the Tolmein Basin toward Karfreit. The direction of the attack of the 12th Silesian Division. Kobariški Muzej (Kobarid Museum)
The 12th Division launched attacks on both banks of the Isonzo.
 
Under the cover of fog and rain, they quickly overwhelmed the defenders who received no artillery support from the heights of Krn and the Kolovrat due to damages to the telephone lines. 

At noon, a forward detachment of 80 men was ambushed by the 4th Bersalieri Brigade of the 62th Division on their way to Idesko near Golobi. But the next German unit arrived with machine guns and pushed the Italians back to Luico (Livek). On the other bank, Kamno was captured at the same time.

The Germans stormed Idersko at 1:00 PM and captured several artillery pieces there. ​
Picture
​

​Without pausing, the 12th Division advanced toward Karfreit (Capporetto). The defenders of the 34th Division were panicked by the speed of the advance. Several loud explosions were heard from the town as the Italians were destroying their munition storage.    

By 2:00 PM, the left wing of the 12th Division reached Karfreit and engaged the 34th Division there. At 3:30 AM, the defenders detonated the bridge across the Isonzo while many retreating Italians were visible on the eastern bank. The fight ended when 2000 men of the defenders surrendered at 4:00 PM. As German troops passed through the street of Karfreit, they received a warm welcome from the Slovene civilians. 

The loss of Karfreit made it impossible for the 43rd and 46th Divisions to continue their fight in the night. At 11:30 PM a total of 15,000 men  of the 43rd Infantry Division surrendered to the Germans at Karfreit.

Meanwhile, some elements of the 12th Infantry Division continued their advance deeper into the enemy territory. By midnight, they were in control of Staro Selo and Golobi. 

The 12th Division advanced 23km under intense gunfire and extreme weather on the first day, an extraordinary accomplishment in the Great War.
Picture
Column of Italian prisoners guarded by German soldiers. Imperial War Museum.

The Alpenkorps: 

Picture
​The Alpenkorps started their offensive from Sv. Maria at the same time as the 12th Silesian Division. 

Their main objective was the fortress on Hill 1114 (Height #1114). On the right, the Bavarian Life Guard Regiment would capture Foni and attack the hill from the North. On the left wing, the 1st Bavarian Jäger Regiment would storm the trenches of Hill 732 and the church at Slemen. From Slemen, they would attack Hill 1114 from the South-East. 

At 9:00 AM, the Alpenkorps captured the first defensive line S.Daniel- Woltschach -Ciginj. 
Picture
German troops moving through the church of St. Daniel near Woltschach. Kobariški Muzej
Picture
The destroyed Italian first trenches at Woltschach. Kobariški Muzej
However, the climb to the Kolovrat Ridge was challenging. Each man had to carry at least 45kg of equipment further weighted down by the pouring rain. The enemy outnumbered them, so they had to move carefully from cover to cover to bypass strong points. 

At noon, the Life Guard Regiment, “frozen and soaked to the bone”, reached the Kovačič Plateau and captured Foni.

Without resting, they attacked Hill 1114 from the North. The defenders were surprised, but they still put up a strong resistance. After a heavy bombardment from the German batteries, the Life Guard finally captured the fortification at 5:30 PM. 
Picture
Italian trenches at Hill 1114. Kobariški Muzej.
Yet, the Bavarian Life Guard Regiment's situation was dangerous.

First the news of capturing Hill 1114 did not reach to the Headquarters of the 14th Army until the early hours of the 25th. Coordination with the artillery and nearby friendly troops was impossible as the Life Guard was surrounded by hostile forces. The only nearby allied troops was the 1st Jäger Regiment.

Nevertheless, the 1st Regiment could not reach their position. They were pinned down in the woods in front of Hill #732. All their attempts to get around and attack from multiple directions failed. Their last attempt in the evening with the help of the 200th Infantry Division from Mt. Ježa did not result in a breakthrough. 

These made the Life Guard Regiment very vulnerable to a counterattack. 

​Berrer’s Group: german LI corps

The prized objective was the fortification at the Ježa Height. This assignment was as challenging as their Alpenkorps’s. To achieve this:
​
  • The 4th Jäger Regiment from the German 200th Infantry Division would climb to the Jesenjak Ridge to assault Hill #428 after conquering Ciginj. 
 
  • The 3rd Jäger Regiment would make a breakthrough at Cemponi before moving north to regroup with the 4th Regiment.
​
  • The 3rd and 4th Regiments, then, would assault on Ježa.
Picture
Albert von Berrer. Commander of the German LI Corps. Killed in Action on October 28th 1917.
Picture
​Things did not go well for the 4th Jäger Regiment. They captured the first line at Ciginj so easily. Most Italian troops had withdrawn from the first trenches to Jesenjak the previous day. 

As they were climbing, they were facing much larger forces than expected who were on favorable grounds. They were pinned down by intense shelling barrages and machine gun fires in front of Hill 428 for several hours to the late evening. 

The situation of the 3rd Jäger Regiment on the left was better. While the defenders put up more fight than expected, the cooperation with the Austrian 7th Mountain Brigade from Scotti’s Group proved fruitful. After hours of fighting, a breakthrough at Cemponi happened before noon.
Without resting, they attacked the Jesenjak Ridge from the south. At 2:00 PM, the chapel at Hill 631 was captured after repeling a fierce counterattack from the elite Alpini of the 19th Infantry Division.

Soon the 3rd Jäger Regiment and the 7th Mountain Brigade secured the ridge and the outlying hills near Jera, allowing the pinned 4th Jäger Regiment to break through Hill 428 at 3:00 PM.

As the Austrian Brigade moved toward Bizaki, the 3rd and 4th Jäger Regiments began the assault on Ježa. This position was well fortified and the defender fought back fiercely. The German regiments exhausted all their available options. Ježa was captured in the evening only after a brutal hand-to-hand combat. 

Some elements of the 3rd and 4th Regiments went north to assist the 1st Bavarian Regiment but failed to change the situation on Height 732.

They were reinforced by the 5th Jäger Regiment at night. 

At the end of the day, Berrer’s Group took thousands of Italian prisoners and captured 99 artillery pieces, 45 trench mortars, and 75 machine guns.
Picture
An illustration of hand-to-hand combat on the Italian Front. La Domenica del Corriee July 1916.

Scotti’s Group: austro-hungarian XV corps

Picture
​The main goal of Scotti’s group was to help the 2nd Isonzo Army cross the Isonzo in the south. To do that they need to secure the heights of Jazne, Globočak, and Kostanjevica.

The assignments for the 1st Austro-Hungary Infantry Division were:
  • The 7th Mountain Brigade would join the 3rd Jäger Regiment in the assault on Cemponi and Jesenjak Ridge. Next, they would advance toward the Globočak with the 22nd Mountain Brigade along the ridge line. 

  • The 22nd Mountain Brigade would storm the Hrad Vrh before attacking the Jazne trenches. 

  • The 5th German Infantry Division would provide support to the operation. ​
Picture
Karl Scotti. Commander of Austro-Hungarian XV Corps.
The assignments for the 1st Division were difficult. They had to conquer the difficult terrain without sufficient artillery support. There was a shell shortage in the south. Their neighboring Kosak’s Group from the 2nd Isonzo Army did not receive enough shells because the breakthrough at Karfreit was the top priority. 

To circumvent the munition shortage, the men of the 7th and 22nd Mountain Brigades had crossed the no man’s land to the foot of the mountain secretly on the night of October 23rd. They hoped to use the element of surprise to close the distance fast. 

Things went favorably for the 7th Brigade. The cooperation with their neighbor the 3rd Jäger Regiment led to the capture of Cemponi at 11:00 AM and the Jesenjak Ridge at 3:00 PM.

The 7th Mountain Brigade, then, pushed toward the Globočak by themselves. After an effective artillery barrage followed by bloody hand-to-hand combat, they captured Pušno and Srednje at 6:00 PM. They could not advance to the Globočak due to darkness and friendly fire barrage.

The assault on the Hrad Vrh by the 22nd Mountain Brigade was costly. Insufficient artillery preparation failed to destroy Italian batteries hidden in the woods. The foggy weather made it impossible for the attackers to locate and use mortars on them.  

The Italians on the Hrad and Jazne resisted to the bitter end even after the loss of Cemponi by noon. Multiple attempts to take those heights were broken under the intensity of the defender guns. Eventually, the isolated defenders were out of munition, and the 22nd Brigade slowly gained the upper hand.  At 4:00 PM, they finally captured both the Hrad Vrh and Jazne. 

Despite their casualties, the 1st Austrian Division took 4,600 prisoners. 77 field guns, and 32 heavy mortars on the first day. They climbed a total of 900 m and advanced 5 km depth into the enemy mountainous territory. This achievement was considered “a first-class contribution to the operation.”

The 2nd Isonzo Army: Kosak's Group

The main objective of Kosak’s group was the Vrh Heights located in the northern part of the Bainsizza-Heiligengeist Plateau.

The imposing Vrh would offer a safe river crossing passage between Auzza and Ronzina. In addition, possessing Vrh would prevent Italian XXIV Korps’ interference with the 14th Army’s operation.


To reach Vrh, the Austro-Hungarian 60th, 35th, and 24th Infantry Divisions had to overcome the trenches east of Torrent Avšček,
Picture
Ferdinand Kosak. Commander of the Kosak's Group.
Picture
​This was a very difficult assignment for Kosak’s group. Not only the enemy's presence was substantially larger, but their artillerymen did not receive enough shells for the offensive. 

Their casualties were the highest on the first day.

​At 8:00 AM, the Austrian 60th Division stormed the trenches in the Isonzo Valley and took 450 prisoners.

The Italian 65th Infantry Division launched a counterattack supported by numerous powerful batteries to retake their position. The 60th Division sustained heavy casualties. They were forced to withdraw back to the starting position before noon. 

In the afternoon, they were reinforced with the 69th Infantry Brigade from the 35th Division. They launched another assault on the trenches in the Mešjak area.

Their attack was not well supported by their batteries due to the shortage. The enemy position was intact, and they unleashed their superior firepower on the attackers. The Austrian casualties were too enormous to continue the assault. The 60th Division was driven back to the starting line. 

The attack on Hoje -Sveti Tomaž section was equally costly.

Artillery preparatory barrage failed to damage enemy positions. Even though the infantry of the 35th and 24th Divisions captured those trenches and the church at Sveti Tomaž, their combat strength was too low to hold them.

​After repelling multiple counterattacks during the day, the 35th Division had to retire to their starting position in the evening. The 24th Division barely defended their gain at Sveti Tomaž.
Picture
Austro-Hungarian soldiers on the Isonzo Front in 1917.
Picture
A church ruined by Austro-Hungarian shell fire on the Italain Front. Imperial War Museum

​Result and Reactions at the end of the first day

The Central Powers

The first day was a huge success for the Central Power.

The HQ of the 14th Army was aware of the impressive breakthroughs at Flitsch and Karfreit. Italian troops were trapped at the Vršič, the Krn, and the Mrzli and the number of prisoners were exceeding their expectations. 

Reports of important victories at Hill 1114, and Ježa did not reach the HQ by 11:00 PM. General of the Infantry Below saw no reason to alter his plan for the second day of the offensive.

The high casualties and the shortage of artillery munitions forced the commander of the 2nd Isonzo Army to alter his plan. General of the Infantry Henriquez decided not to renew the attack on the Avšček trenches. Instead, he instructed Field Marshal Lieutenant Kosak to deploy his reserves to help Scotti’s Group advance toward the Globočak and Kostanjevica on October 25th. 
Picture
Otto von Below, Commander of the Austro-German 14th Army.

The Italian Reactions:

The Italian officials did not expect a major offensive in Karfreit. Chief of Staff Luigi Cardona firmly believed his well-prepared troops and their batteries would break any small-scale offensive.  

When the reports of the Central Powers’ artillery barrage from Mt. Rombom to Görz reached Rome at 8:00 AM, Cardona was dismissive.

As a few telephone lines were still working, information slowly reached the Supreme Command at Udine and the government at Rome. 

At noon, the Minister of War Giardino affirmed that there would be no enemy major offensive until the spring of 1918 in the Italian parliament. Shortly after his speech, he received an urgent report from Udine. The enemy had launched a major offensive from Tolmein.

Confusion soon took over as every new piece of information was worse than the previous. 
​

In the middle of the confusion, Cardona was relaxed. At 6:00 PM, according to Colonel Angelo Gatti, Cardona claimed that the enemy had concentrated his forces on the front where the Italians were strong and well-prepared. Cardona believed that the Italian batteries were roaring thunderously upon the attackers. 

Before 10:00 PM. The scale of the catastrophe shook his confidence off completely. He discovered that the 2nd Army Headquarters was paralyzed for the entire day. Capello, the commander himself, was bedridden. His second-in-command Lieutenant General Badoglio could not grasp the situation after the communication centers were destroyed. The heavy batteries in the back failed to provide the fire support the defending infantry desperately needed. Reserved troops were sent to battles that had been lost. Divisional commanders were afraid of taking the initiative. The Corps leadership traded blame on each other. In some cases, subordinates refused to follow orders from abusive leaders. 

Meanwhile, the German 14th Army advanced at an unprecedented speed, taking as many as 20,000 prisoners.
Picture
Luigi Cadorna. Chief of Staff of the Royal Italian Army
Picture
Gaetano Giardino. Minister of War
Picture
Withdrawing a million men to the Tagliamento to avoid a potential encirclement was not an option. They could not move the 3-year cumulation of equipment out fast because the road conditions were terrible.  

Cardona devised the three resistance lines for his troops to defend at any cost. This would buy him valuable time to slow the Austro-German momentum. These lines started at Ponta. di Montemaggiore:
  • Pta. di Montemaggiore - the Stol - Sarijski - Staro Selo - Mt. Matajur - The Kolovrat Ridge - Jeza - the Globočak
  • Pta. di Montemaggiore - Mt. Lupia - Mt. Mia - Mt. Matajur - Mt. S. Martino - Mt. Hum - the Globočak.
  • Pta. di Montemaggiore - Mt Carnizza - Mt. Juanes - Mt. Madlessena - Mt Purgessimo - Castel del Monte - Korada. 

​Many of the sectors in the first and second lines either had been taken or contested by the advancing troops. More importantly, the hastily retreating Italians could not defend them while leaving their heavy weaponry behind.

Still, Luigi Cardona expected his men to know how to “win or die.”

Note on locations that have different names.

  • Karfreit: Capporetto, Kobarid
  • The Isonzo (River): ​Soča 
  • Flitsch: Bovec, Plezzo
  • Saga: Žaga
  • Stol: Hochstuhl​
  • Vršič: Moistrocca
  • Krn: Monte Nero
  • Luico: Livek
  • Woltschach: Volče​​

Main Sources

  • OSTERREICH-UNGARNS LETZTER KRIEG, 1914-1918. Vol 6. Pg 532-622
The maps were recreated from the Leaflet024 and Leaflet026. 
  • Caporetto and the Isonzo Campaign. The Italian Front 1915-1918. By Željko Cimprić, John Macdonald. ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1848846715
  • The White War: Life and Death on the Italian Front 1915-1919. By Mark Thompson. ISBN-13: ‎ 978-0465020379 
  • Ring of Steel: Germany and Austria-Hungary in World War I. By Alexander Watson. ISBN-13: ‎978-0465094882
  • The Imperial War Museum 
  • The Kobarid Museum 

Read More
0 Comments

11/14/2024 0 Comments

The Twelfth Battle of the Isonzo: Situation on October 23rd 1917

Picture
Tag: Caporetto, Karfreit, Kobarid, the 12th battle of the Isonzo, Italian Front, 1917

The Year of 1917 and the Italian Theather

1917 was not a good year for Austria-Hungary in the Italian theater. They had not recovered from the disastrous Brusilov in the previous year. 

The Kingdom of Italy’s strength significantly increased. With more than a million troops, the Italians outnumbered the Austrians 5 to 2. Britain and France supplied their ally with a large number of heavy artillery batteries and munitions. This made the Kingdom a force to be reckoned with.

The Italians launched two ferocious offensives equal to those on the Western Front. They won the Tenth and Eleventh Battle of the Isonzo (12 May – 8 June 1917; 19 August – 12 September 1917), pushing the Austrian Empire to the brink of collapse. ​
Picture
A panoramic view over a landscape showing Gorizia is on the right and Monte Podgora on the left. In the background, from left to right, are San Daniele, Dol, Monte Sabetino, and Monte Santo. The peaks of Monte Nero are visible on the left. Savogna lies in the middle foreground and the woods on San Michele are in the immediate foreground.
​The Austrians’ elastic defense could not work. There was no place left for them to retreat. The sensitive Hermada Citadel was within the Italian reach. If Hermada felt, the strategic port city of Trieste would surely fall. The loss of it would knock the Austria-Hungary Empire out of the war. The Italians would use their number superiority to extend the frontline which the Austrians had no more troops to spare.
Picture
The Hermada. View from the heights of Monfalcone. 1917.
Picture
Emperor Karl I, Empress Zita and their two children - Otto and Adelheid - inspecting Austro-Hungarian officers in Italy. Imperial War Museum
Picture
Kaiser Karl during the 11th Battle of the Isonzo.
On the 22nd of August, Kaiser Karl I of the Austrian Empire personally inspected the troops on the Isonzo Front. In his letter to Kaiser Wilhelm of the German Empire, he asked the German to relieve Austro-Hungarian divisions on the Eastern Front, so they could be deployed to the South-West Front. In addition, he requested to increase supply of heavy guns, ammunition and war materials. Kaiser Karl did not ask for a direct German intervention as both Austria and Italy considered this front was their separate wars. Germany, Britain, and France did not have any division there. 

But the Austrian Chief of Staff Arthur Freiherr Arz von Straußenburg did not believe this was enough to turn the tide. He sent Major General Waldstätten to meet First Quartermaster General Erich Ludendorff on August 29th to discuss a joined offensive.

Both Kaiser Wilhelm and Ludendorff were hesitated to release those Austrian divisions. 
The Aftermath of the Eleventh Battle changed the calculation. 
​
During the Eleventh Battle, most of the Bainsizza-Heiligengeist Plateau fell to the attackers. The Italians would use this strategic area to cut the Austrian forces in half in their next offensive. ​


The citadel of Hermada was barely hold against the Italian's onslaught.
Picture
Italian troops in the front line trenches on the Karst Plateau (Carso ), Imperial War Museum
In addition to territory losses, the Austrian fighting force was critically low. As for artillery pieces, more than half of the irreplaceable Austrian batteries were captured. The empire could not replenish their losses nor replace their equipment.​
Erich Ludendorff predicted that Austria-Hungary would surrender before 1918. This would leave Germany alone in the war, a consequence that he wanted to avoid at all cost.  

The German General Staff finally agreed ​to a joined counteroffensive.
As Austria had only 21 divisions against 40 Italian divisions, the Central Powers created the German 14th Army from their best troops in the East under the leadership of General der Infanterie Otto von Below.

​It had 17 divisions, 1076 guns, 174 mortars and 31 engineer companies. This Army would be the spearhead of the Fall Offensive.

The Central powers' Plan for the fall Offensive

Picture
Picture
A group of German and Austrian Soldiers having a meal In Tolmein, October 1917. Imperial War Museum.
The main goal of the offensive was to drive the Italians 40 km back to the Tagliamento and beyond. This would shorten the frontline and give favorable terrains for the Austrian defenders.
​
To achieve this, the 14th Army would break through the Italian 2nd Army’s lines at Flitsch (Plezzo) and Tolmein (Tolmin, Tolmino).  Between Flitsch and Tolmien was the the town of Karfreit (Caporetto) which was soon to be a namesake for the Twelve Battle of the Isonzo.
The Offensive would begin in mid-October and end before December. Ludendorff wanted those German divisions back for the Spring Offensive of 1918.
Picture

The Kingdom of Italy after the Eleventh Battle of the Isonzo

Victories in 1917 came with enormous cost. The staggering loss of more than 300,000 men was more than the two previous years. The kingdom could not send more men fast enough before the winter.
Picture
An Italian soldier rescuing a wounded comrade during an attack, carrying him on his back. Imperial War Museum
Picture
Italian soldiers shoveling snow near Monte Marmolada in the Dolomites. Imperial War Museum
In addition, newly acquired territories added more burden to the victors. The road condition was horrible. The lack of roads prevented a sufficient amount of supplies from reaching the frontline. The terrain and bad weather hampered communications and coordination among the battle groups. 
​
Despite all the optimism in Italy, another offensive in 1917 was impossible.

As the Central Powers emerged victorious on the Eastern Front, Marshall of Italy Luigi Cadorna instructed his generals to focus on defense in case of the Central Powers’ attacks.

Despite his instructions, Luigi Cadorna and the Italian leadership did not believe a major Austrian offensive was possible until 1918.
Picture
Chief of Staff Luigi Cadorna.
The Commander of the 2nd Army shared this belief. Luigi Capello, the most abled general, did not follow the instructions and set his troops in an aggressive stance. Most of his troops were deployed in the forward positions at the cost of thinning his defense line. His 2nd and 3rd lines of defense were too close to the first line. Moreover, General Capello concentrated his divisions and batteries on the high ground and neglected the defense in the valley. 

​The main road between Tolmein and Karfreit was lightly defended. This would not be an issue in good weather conditions as the defenders on the high ground had a clear view to fire at the defenseless attackers. However, with extreme weather in October and poor communication, there was nothing to stop the attackers from advancing quickly on this road. ​
Picture
Luigi Capello. Commander of the 2nd Army
Picture
The Tolmein-Karfreit's roads were lightly defended compared to the nearby heights.
Capello’s reason for this aggressive stance was that he believed the offensive was small in scale. It would be shattered by a general counterattack. 
​
As Cardona did not force his general to follow the 18th September instruction, the Capello HQ intentionally misinterpreted his order. 
As signs of an imminent offensive emerged and Capello’s illness was serious, the weaknesses of the 2nd Army were on display. The Italian leadership attempted to adjust the defense, but it was too late. 

At 2:00 AM on October 24th, a massive artillery barrage fired across the Flitsch-and-Tolmein sector. The Twelve Battle of the Isonzo began.

​​Techniques and software:

Those maps were created with Wonderdraft, Inkscape, and GIMP. 

Wonderdraft is a wonderful mapping software that allows users to add symbols and other assets. However, it has shortcomings when the map area is less than 100km square.

To overcome this limit, the mountains have to be drawn painstakingly with the pathing function. One mistake or a change of heart usually takes hours to fix. The risks of corrupting saved files and backup are very high with this technique as the files are large.

For the accuracy and color theme, historical pictures taken in the same month of the Flitsch-Tolmien section the the same period are used. Modern pictures are not reliable because the vegetation from 107 years ago was “less green” compared to nowadays.
 
Inkscape and GIMP are free software that are used to edit the maps created by Wonderdraft. They are also excellent tools to create custom assets.

Sources

  • OSTERREICH-UNGARNS LETZTER KRIEG, 1914-1918. Vol 6. Pg 532-622
The maps were recreated from the Leaflet024 and Leaflet026. 
  • Caporetto and the Isonzo Campaign. The Italian Front 1915-1918. By Željko Cimprić, John Macdonald. ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1848846715
  • The White War: Life and Death on the Italian Front 1915-1919. By Mark Thompson. ISBN-13: ‎ 978-0465020379 
  • Ring of Steel: Germany and Austria-Hungary in World War I. By Alexander Watson. ISBN-13: ‎978-0465094882

Read More
0 Comments

8/8/2023 2 Comments

San Francisco Bay Area, 19th century

2 Comments

3/5/2023 1 Comment

DAS DIETRICBRÜCK GEBIET

1 Comment

12/27/2022 0 Comments

Napoli, Regno Di Sicilia 1362

0 Comments

9/26/2022 0 Comments

bODies OF wATER

0 Comments

5/12/2022 0 Comments

[Fantasy] Sanctuary and Northern Suvia year 637

0 Comments

    Author

    Write something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview.

    Archives

    November 2024
    August 2023
    March 2023
    December 2022
    September 2022
    May 2022

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly